Open this photo in gallery:
UCP members will, once again, battle over the party’s direction at the upcoming annual meeting.AHMED ZAKOT/The Globe and Mail
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has failed to purge separatists from the United Conservative Party’s leadership ranks, a month after decreeing that officials within her organization must be committed to federalism.
Further, Ms. Smith’s demand that all local party presidents stop advocating for Alberta’s secession has aggravated independence advocates and free-speech absolutists ahead of the UCP’s annual meeting next weekend in Calgary.
“We are bitterly divided,” Vince Byfield, once one of Ms. Smith’s most reliable supporters, said at a UCP forum this week.
Ms. Smith has begged her fellow conservatives to focus on winning the 2027 provincial election, which she said will require abandoning the quest for secession given that 75 per cent of Albertans rejected the idea in a referendum last month.
Alberta Premier fends off leadership challenge and looks to squelch separatist discord
She first encouraged Albertans to drop the issue in a televised address after the vote, and again the next day when she told UCP members that separatist agitators were no longer welcome in the party. In late October, her party asked all candidates in the UCP’s coming board elections to sign a pledge committing to respect the referendum results. It has recently expanded that request to its 87 constituency association presidents.
But many of the movement’s leaders are prominent players in the UCP and believe most party members want the organization to continue pushing for separation.
The Premier’s inability to quell dissent means UCP members will, once again, battle over the party’s direction and focus at what is expected to be a raucous annual meeting. The organization has sold roughly 7,000 tickets to the event, where members will elect eight people to the party’s provincial board, which influences the UCP’s strategy, policies and politics.
While the candidates are largely split between two slates, their histories reveal deeper divisions within the party. Mr. Byfield is challenging incumbent Patrick Malkin, a senior official in the Premier’s office, for a vice-president position. Both men first won spots on the provincial board in the fall of 2022, as part of a populist wave that just weeks prior had helped Ms. Smith become party leader.
Open this photo in gallery:
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has maintained her stance that officials within the UCP must be committed to federalism.Jeff McIntosh/The Canadian Press
Now, Mr. Malkin is on the Team Unity slate backing Ms. Smith, and Mr. Byfield is informally aligned with the separatist cluster of candidates.
Dozens of UCP members gathered on Wednesday evening at a private Christian academy in south Calgary for an event dubbed the “Cowtown Showdown,” to hear board candidates make their pitch.
TJ Schmidt, who is running against a Team Unity candidate for a vice-president position, compared the party’s proclivity for infighting to an Olympian with an immune system prone to illness.
“It pits about half the cells in the body against the other half,” he told the crowd. “That strength is still there for that athlete, but it’s turned inwards to fight itself.”
At the end of October, the UCP stripped boisterous independence leader Jeffrey Rath of his membership. At the UCP’s annual meeting last year, Mr. Rath whipped up the crowd in support of secession; the audience booed Ms. Smith when she responded by touting Alberta’s renewed relationship with Ottawa.
Alberta separatist leader Jeffrey Rath expelled from UCP
Mr. Rath’s removal gave credibility to Ms. Smith’s post-referendum promise to focus on the 2027 election. Party members, including separatist sympathizers, cheered his removal.
However, large pockets within the party have rejected Ms. Smith’s broader housecleaning effort.
Earlier this month, the UCP demanded its 87 constituency association presidents respect and abide by the results of October’s referendum question on separation, effectively ordering them to stop publicly pushing for independence. The deadline elapsed without full compliance.
Fifteen presidents openly defied Ms. Smith by releasing a letter stating the dictate exceeded the party’s power. The signatories include Mitch Sylvestre, a key separatist organizer who fiercely supported the Premier in the past.
Ms. Smith has yet to specify – let alone mete out – consequences for refusing to comply. Instead, she said last week that she would continue her persuasion campaign.
The party brass has not yet discussed repercussions, according to UCP president Rob Smith, who defended the organization’s decree. “Is it not reasonable to actually expect those individuals to recognize, respect and abide by a decision that was made by 75 per cent of Albertans?”
Mr. Smith, who is not up for re-election this year and is not related to the Premier, declined to share his position on separation, but said he is “satisfied that the issue has been laid to rest.”
Asked whether he believes the secession conversation is over within the UCP, Mr. Smith said: “In the short term, it is.”
Alberta’s new electoral map may not tilt the province, but it could help the UCP retain its majority
UCP spokesman Dave Prisco backed the Premier’s diplomatic approach to dissent.
“We’re going to work with people respectfully,” he said in an e-mailed statement.
The outcome of October’s referendum question on separation raised the stakes in the fight for control over the UCP’s provincial board and the makeup of its constituency associations. Ms. Smith could face a leadership review if two-thirds of the provincial directors vote in favour of a special general meeting, or if 22 of 87 constituency associations call for one.
Board candidates running with the Team Unity slate launched an e-mail blitz this week.
“We must stand united behind our party’s leader, Danielle Smith and her call to respect the results of the recent referendum and, as a party, commit to a strong Alberta within a United Canada,” Ken Engler, a candidate for the party’s chief financial officer, said in an e-mail.
Mr. Engler, who did not acknowledge an interview request, was first elected treasurer in 2022, after serving as Ms. Smith’s CFO during her leadership campaign. He does not currently sit on the board.
While the UCP expects record crowds at its annual meeting, and the voting booths will only be open for five hours, Mr. Engler encouraged prospective attendees to be in the main convention hall for Saturday’s keynote address.
“Hear Premier Smith speak and cheer her on.”