Open this photo in gallery:

Ontario Premier Doug Ford attempted to speak French while giving a speech at the Chamber of Commerce of Metropolitan Montreal on Tuesday.Peter McCabe/The Canadian Press

John Diefenbaker’s French was dire. Though he was a stirring orator, he never learned the language and spoke it haltingly when he served as prime minister in the 1950s and 1960s. Audiences would wince when, jowls shaking, he would say: “Mesdames et messieurs, permettez-moi de vous adresser quelques mots dans la langue française.”

But he was a master of tongues compared with Doug Ford. The Ontario Premier was in Montreal this week addressing the chamber of commerce. In the spirit of friendship between neighbouring provinces, he decided to try out his French. It did not go well.

Obviously nervous, staring fixedly and a little desperately at his teleprompter, he staggered through his own “quelques mots,” mispronouncing most of them. When he said that Ontario and Quebec should “travaillons ensemble,” it came out as something like “tryon sambla.” When he wished “longue vie” to Quebec, Ontario and Canada, he rendered the “vie” like the via in Via Rail.

Doug Ford says learning French ‘rougher than I thought’ after Montreal speech

Most people who grew up in Canada can at least put together a few words of French. Mr. Ford spoke almost as if he had never heard the language, even though he has repeatedly mentioned working on his French skills since becoming Premier in 2018.

Not since John Travolta introduced singer and actress Idina Menzel as the “wickedly talented, one and only, Adele Dazeem” at Hollywood’s Academy Awards has someone committed such a massive face plant. As they say in Quebec, “il s’est planté royalement.”

Ford’s opponents in Ontario jumped all over him for it. NDP Leader Marit Stiles said the episode was embarrassing and “a little insulting” to French-speaking Ontarians. Interim Liberal Leader John Fraser felt it was “not something to laugh about” (though just about everyone did, including Mr. Ford’s Montreal audience). Mr. Fraser said he had heard someone suggest that what the Premier did to the French language was a hate crime, though he himself thought that was exaggerating. Oh, just a tiny bit.

Mr. Ford was apologetic about his fractured français, telling his listeners that the prospect of giving the speech had kept him awake at night. In the midst of one of his heroic attempts to form a French sentence, he stopped to say, “I’m really messing this one up.”

In truth, nobody expects to hear a guy like Mr. Ford to speak good French. He grew up in a Toronto suburb and, like many people in English Canada, never had much call to use the language of Champlain.

The plain fact is that though Canada may be a bilingual country by law, in practice it is not. More than half a century has passed since the enactment of the Official Languages Act ushered in the era of government-backed bilingualism. Yet less than one in five Canadians are truly bilingual – one in 10 outside of Quebec.

English universities reach deal with Quebec on French-language rules

The bilingualism we do have – highway signs, labelling, proficiency requirements for civil servants – is mainly symbolic. If the aim of this noble gesture was to discourage separatism by making French Canadians feel fully included in the Canadian family, it has failed spectacularly. Successive nationalist governments of Quebec have devoted themselves to enforcing official unilingualism within its borders.

Yes, anglophones who aspire to high national office are expected to speak at least passable French. Good. About 20 per cent of Canadians have French as their mother tongue. Quebec is an important battleground in federal elections and any prime minister must deal with the Quebec question. We have evolved since Dief was the chief.

Politicians at lower levels are another question. Some are bilingual. Manitoba’s charismatic NDP Premier Wab Kinew speaks French. So does Naheed Nenshi, the former mayor of Calgary who leads the NDP in Alberta. Many others do not.

Mr. Ford stands out only for the level of his inability. But it seems wrong to blame him for it. Some people are just not good at languages. Many of us in English Canada are ashamed of our French, especially if we visit Quebec. At least he tried.

Mr. Ford was properly sheepish when asked later about his big fail in Montreal. As he put it, “Man, I need French lessons, big time.”