Open this photo in gallery:

A person uses a cell phone in Ottawa on July 18, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean KilpatrickSean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press

For years, the big Canadian telecoms were sitting pretty. Within their cozy little oligopoly, they were shielded from competition, free to charge some of the highest prices in the world, while being fed a steady supply of new arrivals to Canada in need of cellphone plans.

The good old days, as investors call them.

As much as this model shortchanged wireless consumers, it was a different story if you held stock in the telcos. Shares of the big three – Bell, Rogers, and Telus – rose by an average of roughly 400 per cent over a 12-year period starting in 2010, after you factor in dividends. That’s nearly 15 per cent a year.

Then it all fell apart, beginning around 2022. Interest rates leapt higher, tight immigration curbs were put in place, cord-cutting increased, and regulators paved the way for the entry of smaller competitors.

Since then, the telecom sector has been portfolio poison. The group of stocks is down by more than 35 per cent, on average, at a time when the stock market at large has been screaming higher.

And now, another shakeup of the sector is in play. Quebecor Inc. is proposing to reduce the number of players in the national wireless market once again with a bid to acquire Telus Corp.

Could this be the move that resuscitates the sector? The stock market itself is suggesting it’s a distant long shot.

You can tell how credible investors think a takeover offer is by how much the stock moves in reaction to the news. Quebecor’s bid of $19.45 per share represented a 60-per-cent premium to Telus’s closing price on Friday.

If investors felt like the deal might be a 50-50 proposition, you might see Telus shares jump by closer to 30 per cent. As of the closing bell on Tuesday, they’re up just 9 per cent.

There are monumental regulatory hurdles standing in the way. And it’s unlikely the federal government will okay anything that imperils affordability. Policymakers have spent a few years now fostering greater competition, with some success.

Statistics Canada’s inflation data show the cost of cellphone services declining by more than 40 per cent over the past five years. And that’s part of the problem for the incumbents. They’ve been forced to match lower-cost plans to avoid losing customers.

Across the board, the financial metrics tell a story of an industry under pressure. Wireless profit margins are on the decline. Same with average revenue per user. Streaming has put the squeeze on the cable television business model.

Canadian income investors once cherished telecom stocks for their stability and immense profitability, which kept the dividends flowing. These companies didn’t need to waste money chasing growth and market share. The market was theirs for the taking.

The oligopoly model is a bit of a Canadian specialty. Like the telecoms, Canada’s banks, grocers, railways, and airlines are also shielded behind barriers to entry and limited competition.

Canadian consumers rightfully complain about the high fees and poor service that such a system tends to produce. But the consumer’s loss is the investor’s gain, for better or worse.

In the telecom sector, at least, the balance has shifted. Better affordability and more competition have weighed on telecom earnings and, ultimately, stock market performance and dividend payouts. In the past year and a half, both BCE and Telus have cut their quarterly dividends by at least half – a cardinal sin in a country that treats dividends as sacrosanct.

Investors will surely be keeping an eye on Quebecor’s gambit, but the sector’s glory days seem like a distant memory.