Open this photo in gallery:

The Supreme Court released a pair of rulings that seek to bring more clarity to complex sexual-assault cases.Justin Tang/The Canadian Press

The Supreme Court of Canada has sharpened the legal focus on questions around the issue of consent in sexual-assault cases with the release of two related judgments on Friday.

The rulings aim to bring additional clarity to the increasingly complicated nature of sexual-assault trials.

In the judgments, the court said there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact and that judges at trial must instruct juries on consent in sexual-assault cases.

One case started in Ontario, where a provincial court trial judge acquitted Bevin Kerry Deagle of aggravated sexual assault in 2023. The Ontario Court of Appeal in 2024 overturned that ruling and entered a conviction for the crime.

The Supreme Court on Friday unanimously rejected Mr. Deagle’s appeal and upheld his conviction. The court, however, split 5-4 on legal reasoning, with the majority judgment written by Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau.

Justice Sheilah Martin, who retired at the end of May, wrote the concurring reasons, in one of her final cases. Her work on issues of consent in sexual-assault cases is among her legacies from her eight-plus years on the Supreme Court.

The other case settled on Friday began in Alberta, where Jordan Bilinski was acquitted of sexual assault after a superior court jury trial in 2023. In 2025, the Alberta Court of Appeal overturned that ruling and ordered a new trial.

The Supreme Court, by a 7-2 margin, rejected Mr. Bilinski’s appeal and upheld the order for a new trial. Justice Martin wrote the majority judgment.

The top court heard the two cases May 21 and 22, at the end of the spring session. The hearings marked the last days on the bench for Justice Martin. She is allowed to participate in judgments until the end of this month.

Justice Martin joined the Supreme Court from Alberta in late 2017, when former chief justice Beverley McLachlin retired. Through her years on the top court, Justice Martin garnered a reputation for expertise in criminal law and Charter of Rights and Freedoms cases.