
Open this photo in gallery:
A view of Pelee Island’s southern tip – Fish Point in May. Because of the island’s geographic position at the confluence of two major migration corridors, it is internationally renowned for birdwatching.Melissa Tait/The Globe and Mail
Thousands of birding advocates have sent messages asking the federal government to intervene in a U.S. company’s plan to build an enormous radio tower on Pelee Island in southwestern Ontario.
The picturesque Lake Erie isle, which covers about 40 square kilometres, is home to Canada’s southernmost community.
Conservation groups and residents are raising concerns that the planned 182-metre tower, along with the cables needed to support it, would become a deadly obstacle for the hundreds of thousands of birds that traverse the island during annual spring and fall migrations each year.
The tower is slated to be built next year on township land leased by DRW Holdings, LLC, a private trading company based in Chicago. It is intended to facilitate the rapid transmission of stock trading data to the east coast of the United States via microwaves.
It was approved by the island’s township council last year, but many property owners say they only become aware of the full scope of the project this summer.
That includes Canadian literary icon Margaret Atwood, who has resided on the island part-time for decades. Together with her late husband Graeme Gibson, she helped to establish the Pelee Island Bird Observatory, which tracks avian activity through one of North America’s busiest bird flyways.
Because of the island’s geographic position at the confluence of two major migration corridors, it and nearby Point Pelee National Park are internationally renowned for birdwatching. In September, the observatory opened a new $3.5-million research facility, funded by Ms. Atwood and others.
On Thursday, Ms. Atwood posted a message on her Substack alerting followers to the potential implications of the tower for migrating bird species, many of which move at night when they are more likely to be affected by a tower’s flashing lights and susceptible to collisions with unseen cables.
“If you wanted to kill a lot of birds with a huge, deadly tower—a LOT of birds—you couldn’t have planned it better,” Ms. Atwood wrote.
Ms. Atwood also invited people to fill out a digital letter that will be sent to Canada’s Minister of Environment, Julie Dabrusin, and the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada, the federal organization that has the jurisdiction to decide whether a project requires an environmental assessment before it can proceed. Another recipient is Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, which has yet to grant DRW a licence to broadcast from the planned tower.
The period for public comment on the project expires on Monday.
Open this photo in gallery:
A Yellow Warbler is recovered from the nets near the PIBO banding station on Pelee Island. Residents fear the planned tower would become a deadly obstacle for the many birds that traverse the island.Melissa Tait/The Globe and Mail
Matthew Gibson, one of Graeme Gibson’s sons, who sits on the bird observatory’s board and is spearheading its public awareness campaign, said that as of Sunday evening, the effort has generated upwards of 26,000 letters calling for a federal assessment of the tower.
That includes a letter from the township’s property-owners’ association, which notes the degree to which the island’s economy and real estate values depend on nature-based tourism.
The letter also notes that an impact study commissioned by the company does not assess bird collisions.
In statements to media, DRW has said it is committed to mitigating the impact of the tower on birds.
Despite the council’s approval of the tower last year, many residents did not know of it until a council meeting in July when a second tower by a different proponent was voted down. Social media groups about the topic reveal some public confusion, including the mistaken impression that the tower will be used to improve cellphone service on the island.
Individually, some residents have expressed frustration over a lack of transparency about the DRW tower, and the fact that no public meeting was called to provide information about the project.
“It’s preposterous and it’s appalling all at the same time,” said Ron Tiessen, who has lived on Pelee Island for 47 years.
Mr. Tiessen added that the tower would be a “visual blemish,” obvious from any location on the island, in addition to its environmental impacts.
The details of the township’s agreement struck with DRW, including the amount that the municipality will receive for leasing the property for the tower, have not been made public.
In an e-mail to The Globe and Mail, Cathy Miller, who just completed her four-year term as mayor of the township, said the council had met its obligations according to federal rules and Ontario’s Municipal Act.
In August, in an e-mail exchange with the bird observatory’s board chair, Deborah Egan, obtained by The Globe, Ms. Miller wrote that the lease would raise significant revenue for township infrastructure, which she said would have been irresponsible for her to ignore.
Ms. Miller also helped to set up a meeting between DRW and representatives of the bird observatory, but the discussion did not shed much more light on the details of the project, said Mr. Gibson.
The conservation organization Birds Canada also sent a representative to that meeting to participate in the discussion with DRW.
In a statement, David Browne, senior vice-president for conservation and policy at the organization, said “Birds Canada is very concerned that the tower will not be designed to eliminate impacts on birds and will become an ongoing source of mortality.”
Ms. Egan said that the bird observatory’s board is now pursuing a freedom of information request to learn the details of the township’s arrangement with DRW.
Dave DeLellis, the incoming mayor, who was also on the council when it approved the tower, said he was not able to respond to questions about the matter but that it would be a “top priority” for the new council after it is sworn in on Tuesday.