
Interested in more careers-related content? Check out our new weekly Work Life newsletter. Sent every Monday afternoon.
There’s no shortage of advice about how to be more productive: Get up earlier. Make a schedule. Set priorities. Or download the latest time management app.
Getting things done efficiently has become big business: The market size of global productivity apps was recently valued at US$13.15-billion and is projected to grow to US$30.85-billion by 2034. That’s a lot of money riding on the idea that we could all be getting more done if we just found the right system. And when those methods don’t work, we tend to assume the problem is us.
But what if the problem isn’t how we’re managing our time but what our brains are capable of doing with it? Research suggests our cognitive abilities fluctuate depending on our environment or what we’re experiencing.
In a recent University of Toronto study, researchers tracked students over 12 weeks using brief daily tests to measure the speed and accuracy of their thinking. They found participants accomplished more on days when they were “mentally sharper,” even after accounting for personality traits such as self-control, conscientiousness and grit.
The findings suggest that productivity is more than a matter of trying harder.
Cendri Hutcherson, an associate professor of psychology at the University of Toronto and a co-author of the study, compares the experience of reduced mental sharpness to watching an old television with a poorly adjusted antenna: You can still see what’s happening, but the static makes everything more difficult to interpret.
“We basically have mental static,” says Dr. Hutcherson, who is also director of the Toronto Decision Neuroscience Laboratory.
She says performing the same mental tasks requires more effort when information isn’t being processed as clearly.
What causes static is unclear, Dr. Hutcherson adds.
For example, cognitive capacity may be influenced by how much we’ve been working and how much sleep we’ve been getting.
“You could buy all the productivity enhancers and try all the advertised techniques,” she says. “And I think you would still have good and bad days.”
The trouble with trying harder
Our mental abilities depend heavily on what’s happening in the prefrontal cortex, the part of your brain that sits behind your forehead and helps with attention, emotions, self-control and decision-making, says Adele Diamond, a professor of developmental cognitive neuroscience at the University of British Columbia.
It’s this part of the brain that manages higher-level cognitive processes known as executive functions, which Dr. Diamond has spent decades studying.
“Executive functions are very effortful,” she says, adding that they require us to consciously direct our attention and regulate our behaviour, rather than relying on automatic responses.
“It’s always better not to have to rely on willpower,” Dr. Diamond says.
Working memory is one of our executive functions, Dr. Diamond says, allowing us to hold information while doing something else. But rather than relying on it to remember every detail of a meeting, we take notes or make a recording.
Dr. Diamond says people should approach self-control the same way: Rather than expecting ourselves to summon more willpower, she suggests changing our surroundings to make tasks easier. It might mean reducing distractions or creating reminders. She calls this scaffolding: support that helps people do things they might otherwise struggle with. The approach recognizes human limitations rather than treating them as personal failures.
Stress makes things worse, Dr. Diamond says, citing research showing that even mild stress can impair executive function. Contrary to the belief that a little pressure helps people perform, her research suggests stress can undermine the cognitive abilities required to meet demanding expectations.
The implications for workplaces are significant. Employers who believe they’re motivating workers by putting them under more pressure may actually be making it harder for them to perform.
Constant interruptions present another problem. Each disruption interferes with focused attention, forcing us to recover our train of thought before continuing. Research by cognitive psychologists Erik Altmann and J. Gregory Trafton found that interruptions create a “resumption lag,” as people need time to recover their train of thought before continuing.
Can you buy your way to better productivity?
Dr. Hutcherson thinks there’s too much emphasis on willpower and questions the idea that productivity is just a matter of discipline. Research suggests that genuinely wanting to do the work, enjoying it or caring about the goals we’re pursuing may be better predictors of productivity than self-discipline, she says.
While productivity tools can be helpful, researchers say they can’t eliminate the cognitive limitations that affect how much people accomplish.
Dr. Hutcherson suggests you “have a little compassion for yourself on the days that things don’t go as planned.”