Open this photo in gallery:
Aleris is one of the health care providers at the Sabbatsberg Hospital site in Stockholm, where they offer specialized clinics and outpatient services.Felix Odell/The Globe and Mail
Experts are calling for new ideas to help improve Canada’s health care and education systems, and one solution can be found in an unexpected place: Sweden.
A high-tax, socialist country not politically dissimilar to Canada, Sweden also has a robust private health care and education system.
On Nov. 12, Financial reporter Tim Kiladze answered reader questions on Sweden’s models, how Sweden pivoted to increased private services after a financial crisis and the big moves needed to improve Canada’s health care and education systems.
Even socialist Sweden has robust private health care and education. Why shouldn’t Canada?
Readers asked how Sweden’s systems work, Canada’s roadblocks and the path to better services. Here are some highlights from the Q&A.
Open this photo in gallery:
Stockholm, Sweden.Felix Odell/The Globe and Mail
The Swedish system
What put Sweden on your radar in the first place?
Kiladze: Funny enough, there was a story in the Wall Street Journal earlier this year that very loosely addressed how Sweden had adopted these private models. Their framing was a bit different. They didn’t say this directly, but it seemed to take an anti-Mamdani stance in NYC and suggest, ‘Why would we (the U.S.) look to public models when even Sweden wants to be more like us?’ I thought it would be quite interesting to take the lens of what it could mean for Canada.
To be clear, though, the Swedish model has been written about quite a bit over the years. In our database, I even found one of my colleagues wrote about the private hospital in Stockholm in 2001. But I thought it would be a good time to revisit, given there’s now been three decades of experimentation, plus, our deficits just keep piling up and we don’t really have raising taxes as an option.
What can we learn from the Swedish system that can realistically be applied to Canada?
Kiladze: What really came through in the reporting is that Swedish values, and public scrutiny, have kept the private systems in check. The same goes with strict guardrails around the private models.
For instance, in the education system, the independent schools can’t cherry pick students – it’s effectively a first-come, first-serve wait-list.
Another major point: The rate of unionization in Sweden is quite high. There is a running joke there: The only employees who aren’t unionized are Tesla employees. That’s not fully true, but private employers often have to at least follow the precedents set by collective bargaining agreements.
Of course, no single system is ever going to be perfect. But the fact that these two systems have persisted in Sweden for 30 years really stood out to me.
Is there a sliding scale in Sweden for pay based on income if one chooses private care?
Kiladze: The ‘private care’ phrase here is thrown around a little too liberally. Keep in mind that it’s ‘privately-run’ care, but publicly-funded.
There are some people who can benefit from better access, perhaps through their work benefits. (In Sweden, some employers will grant medical coverage that includes certain surgeries, whereas in Canada ours is often limited to dental and physiotherapy, etc.)
And it is a very serious concern, so I’m not downplaying it by any means. But that’s what’s so interesting about the Swedish model – it’s more that the operations are managed by a business, but the government pays.
A comparison is also made to private schools – they are mostly able to select their students, so they skim off the easiest and best cases. Public schools, on the other hand, have to take every student. How does Sweden handle the cherry picking?
Kiladze: This was one of the most interesting things I learned about. In Sweden, they effectively can’t cherry pick. Once you register, you’re in a queue, and it’s more or less first come first serve.
It’s tricky to get overall stats, and there are a number of independent school networks which each have their own makeups, but the one I talked to at length, Kunskapsskolan, stressed that they actually have a slightly higher ratio of immigrant students to domestically-born ones, relative to the Swedish public school system.
It can get very complicated. Immigrants are a broad category and you need to delve into where the students come from, because an immigrant who grew up in Denmark is likely going to have a very different background than someone who came from an impoverished background.
But overall, it became clear that after 30 years, the independent system has had to iron out a lot of these issues.
Open this photo in gallery:
A health care worker at Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children.Chris Young
Improving Canada’s systems
Why we would be considering privatizing when we underfund our current health care system? Shouldn’t we just support what we have?
Kiladze: Throwing more money at the Canadian system may not be enough. As someone who deeply values public health care, I wish it would be, but there are people like hospital CEOs who have warned that we need to think differently.
Also, even if we do throw more money at the system, where is it going to come from? The recent federal budget just showed continued deficits – and a lot of money now has to be spent on defence – and many provinces are also in the red. I wish there was a big pot of money to throw around, but because there isn’t, it’s worth assessing how the system is actually run day-to-day.
Again, that doesn’t mean we need to go as far as Sweden. But what if there are certain chokepoints that could be fixed? Would a private MRI clinic, funded by taxpayer dollars, help?
The challenge for Canada is staffing the current health system with the limited number of health professionals available. A parallel private system would require significantly more health professionals. Which level of government would cover the cost of expanding health education institutions?
Kiladze: Staffing is a major issue, no doubt. And it’s something I worry about as a Canadian who uses health care. But keep in mind that the private system doesn’t have to be a U.S.-style where people jump from the public system to make way more money. If it’s privately-run, but publicly funded, the government can still cap how much they’re willing to pay for each surgery, etc.
What we certainly need, though, are more health care professionals. Going through all the OECD data, I realized Canada has one of the worst performances when it comes to training doctors. No one likes to say it out loud, but we more or less outsourced a lot of training to foreign countries, and then hire those doctors here. (It’s why the spat with Saudi Arabia about a decade ago was a real problem – there were a lot of Saudi health care professionals working here.)
There are lots of inefficiencies within the system causing delays and costing money. How can that be resolved?
Kiladze: One of the problems we’ve had in Canada, I’d argue, is that we tend to throw money at the problem to try to fix it.
For starters, that’s already been problematic, because we aren’t throwing enough money. The cost of health care keeps rising because of things like demographics and aging baby boomers, so the funding isn’t even keeping up.
But second, more money probably isn’t going to be the answer. We need to look at the major bottlenecks in the system, like long-term care beds. A lot of hospital beds get taken up by people who should be moved to long-term care (which is much cheaper per day) but there just aren’t spots. And then that messes up the whole chain of operation in a hospital. You can’t perform a surgery that needs a day or two of recovery in-hospital if there are no beds to transfer the patient to, for instance.
Where is the political blockage in Canada to the reforms that Sweden undertook and those in the Netherlands in the early 2000s?
Kiladze: My read is that this stems from our relationship to the U.S. Americans tend to be the only thing that Canadians compare themselves to. And U.S. health care in particular is a mess – the highest spending per capita in the OECD, with one of the lowest overall outcomes for patients.
But I think there’s even more to it. I’ve found we hold our history of public health care as an overriding value. Which is great. I’m all for it. But we use it as a bit of a knee jerk response to everything. We’ll look at U.S. economic growth and say ‘fine, but we have universal health care.’
The U.K. arguably does the same, and the NHS has a lot of the same problems as Canadian health care.
I think what would really help is having someone who perhaps has a more centrist or even a liberal political leaning come forward from inside the system and say, the current model is not working. Because when the idea of a private model only comes from conservatives, it doesn’t seem as genuine.
Are you aware of the impact of privatization in Australia on the public system? Do we really want a country where we have to save up for a knee replacement because the wait times in the under-resourced public sector have gotten so long?
Kiladze: It’s one of the things I worry about most.
What we have now, though, also isn’t cutting it. That doesn’t mean we should do exactly what Australia (or any other country) has done, but I think it’s helpful for Canadians to take a hard look at the system and say, this just isn’t sustainable. It can at least get us debating which tweaks could help, versus rejecting any other model outright.
Will a private health care system degrade the public one in areas like recruitment and health care salaries in the public system?
Kiladze: This is a major concern, and I wish I had a good answer to it.
What I can tell you is that having at least some limited private health care has not significantly downgraded the public system in Sweden. I often heard that in Stockholm, for instance, residents often don’t even know that that one of their main hospitals, Saint Goran, is privately run, while the others aren’t.
I also think that we need to assess the flip side to this question. Look at how many people are leaving the public system in Canada already, even though it’s all public – nurses especially. Conditions post-COVID seem to be horrendous. Burnout is extremely high.
Adding a private model doesn’t necessarily need to be the fix, but I find we always fear monger and say, well, private has got to be worse than what we’ve got, and we ignore how bad things already are.