Open this photo in gallery:

Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau says combining networks will be easier for the company, and ‘less costly than being forced to build a tower and pay for it.’Cole Burston/The Globe and Mail

Quebecor QBR-B-T chief executive Pierre Karl Péladeau has made an audacious proposal: He wants to acquire larger rival Telus Corp. T-T at a 60-per-cent premium.

The pitch comes at a vulnerable moment for Telus, whose shares have plummeted as the company grapples with a heavy debt load and uncertain growth prospects.

If the deal went through, that would mean Canada’s count of major telecoms would shrink from four to three. That’s the idea that Mr. Péladeau has been shopping around Ottawa’s top decision makers. But for the head of Telus, which now sits within its rival’s sights, the math doesn’t add up.

A combined Quebecor-Telus unit, Mr. Péladeau is arguing, would be in a better position to invest in Canada’s telecom network and compete with global technology companies, like Elon Musk’s Starlink.

Open this photo in gallery:

Telus CEO Victor Dodig says that the proposed dual-class share structure ‘doesn’t work’ for the company.Fred Lum/The Globe and Mail

But for Telus chief executive Victor Dodig, the unsolicited pitch is full of holes. Not only does it ignore the significant regulatory hurdles without proposing substantial solutions, he argued on Monday, it also fails to recognize the full value of Telus’s assets.

Regardless, his company now has a fiduciary duty to assess the pitch – and to consider other offers as well.

The Globe and Mail met the two CEOs separately Monday and pressed them for details on key issues. Here’s what they told us.

Investing in new infrastructure

Mr. Péladeau and Mr. Dodig are aligned in the idea that Canada needs to build networks in order to secure its sovereignty, and to support the next generation technology that will drive the country’s economy. But whether to buy or build is where they butt heads.

For Mr. Dodig, the key is building networks. “If any competitor has ambitions to build and to grow in this country and grow outside their own region, they should invest in it,” he said, speaking at The Globe’s Toronto headquarters.

Quebecor makes $31-billion bid to acquire Telus in deal that would remake telecom sector

Mr. Péladeau takes a different approach to network expansion, which relies on efficiency instead of duplication and would create cost savings on the operational side, he said.

“Instead of building another network, buy the actual network. If we were to run on the same network, then it will be more logical, more rational for the country,” Mr. Péladeau said during an interview at Freedom Mobile’s Toronto office.

Combining networks will be easier for the company, and “less costly than being forced to build a tower and pay for it,” Mr. Péladeau said.

Dual-class share structure

If the deal goes forward, Telus shareholders would hold approximately 54-per-cent economic interest and 23 per cent of the votes in the combined company

Mr. Dodig said that for Telus, that structure “doesn’t work.”

Opinion: Mélanie Joly is speaking a new language on potential Quebecor-Telus deal

“The special voting shares structure is one of the serious concerns that we have, especially in an industry like this,” he said. “Many families have proven that they can operate like that. But in mission-critical industries like this, I think you need to make sure that you have broad shareholding of investors.”

But Mr. Péladeau is unwilling to budge. Would he consider giving up the dual-class share structure, which would ensure he maintains control of the company?

“Certainly not,” he said. “We want to manage this company. And to manage the company, I need the control. That’s it.”

Regulatory hurdles

The largest barriers to overcome will be those set by Canada’s regulatory agencies, including the Competition Bureau, which will be watching carefully to ensure the deal does not harm consumers.

Mr. Péladeau acknowledges the deal is not a “slam dunk,” but framed the issue as a matter of explaining the benefits and potential cost synergies to regulators. He uses the company’s expansion of Freedom Mobile as an example.

“We were able to be more efficient and liberate financial resources. The Bureau knows this, or if they don’t know it, we will explain it,” he said.

Quebecor’s Freedom Mobile is enjoying a newfound status

But Telus said Quebecor’s proposal does not address the substantial regulatory and execution risk, and it does not suggest potential remedies – such as divestitures – for government concerns.

“Given the regulatory hurdle, anything like this would be a process that would take time,” Mr. Dodig said. “At a time where everyone’s saying, ‘Build more resilience in the industry; build this East-West network; build the fence against Starlink,’ this is not the right time.”

Leverage and debt

Quebecor plans to borrow $10-billion to pay the cash portion of its cash-and-stock offer. That would add debt to what was the strongest balance sheet in telecom, moving Quebecor’s debt-to-EBITDA ratio (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) to 4.1 times, from the current ratio of 2.7 times.

Mr. Dodig said: “The fact that we are actually adding another turn of leverage to an industry that’s more levered, that doesn’t work.”

Mr. Péladeau’s response: “We know what a leveraged company is all about. We bought Videotron and it was seven times [referring to debt-to-EBITDA ratio] and we’ve been reducing it,” he said. “Then we bought Freedom Mobile, and now we have the strongest balance sheet.”

Meeting the moment

There’s one area where the two CEOs are aligned: the fact that this is an opportunistic proposal.

“This is the right time to be investing in the infrastructure to get these projects moving, to not create clouds of dust from opportunistic situations,” Mr. Dodig said.

As for Mr. Péladeau: “Is it opportunistic? Yes. Is it something wrong? I would say no.”

“Our stock is at $70, and their stock is at $12,” he added. “The market decided; we didn’t decide what their stock is.”