Open this photo in gallery:
Foodtastic CEO Peter Mammas, shown at a Milestones in Pointe-Claire, Que., last year, said feedback from MTY shareholders and analysts ‘reinforces that our proposal is compelling and provides certainty for investors.’Christopher Katsarov/The Canadian Press
Canadian restaurant franchiser Foodtastic Inc. says it is gaining investor support in its effort to take over rival MTY Food Group Inc. MTY-T, but share price data suggests there’s still plenty of skepticism that it will clinch a deal.
Since privately held Foodtastic announced an offer to buy publicly traded MTY for roughly $1-billion two weeks ago, shareholders of the target company have told them “they believe the proposal is attractive and want the MTY board of directors to engage constructively” in renewed talks, Foodtastic said in a statement Monday.
It wasn’t immediately clear which MTY investors Foodtastic has spoken to or what level of support Foodtastic has been able to rally for its offer. Foodtastic said its preference is still to do a friendly deal and it urged MTY shareholders to share their views with the MTY board.
“We’re encouraged by the feedback we’ve received from MTY’s own shareholders and analysts, which reinforces that our proposal is compelling and provides certainty for investors,” Foodtastic chief executive Peter Mammas said in the statement.
MTY did not respond to a request for comment.
A merger of the two Montreal-based companies would create a quick-service and casual-dining giant, with some 8,200 restaurants and more than 100 brands across Canada and the United States. Foodtastic is known for banners such as Milestones and Pita Pit while MTY runs Thai Express, Manchu Wok and Cold Stone Creamery, among other names.
Foodtastic went public Nov. 3 with a $43-per-share cash offer for MTY after MTY put an end to earlier talks between the two companies. Foodtastic says MTY has “unrealistic expectations about its value” and questioned whether MTY’s newly named CEO, director Victor Mandel, can reverse the company’s recent underperformance.
MTY hasn’t said much publicly about Foodtastic’s approach. It confirmed it considered Foodtastic’s proposal but concluded it was not in the best interest of the company or its shareholders. It has also cast doubts over Foodtastic’s ability to fund a transaction.
MTY shares are trading at about $36.25 on the Toronto Stock Exchange, well below Foodtastic’s offer. That suggests investors remain unconvinced that the two companies will reach an agreement.
The proposal, worth roughly $1-billion on an equity basis and $1.5-billion including debt, represents a 32-per-cent premium to the Montreal-based MTY’s closing share price on Oct. 30.
MTY traces its origins back to Hong Kong émigré Stanley Ma, who is currently its chairman and largest shareholder. He held a 13.9-per-cent stake as of April, according to S&P Capital IQ data. The next biggest shareholder is Fidelity Investments with an 11.27-per-cent position.